November 18th, 2009 (12:29 am)
Shall Not Bear False Witness:
(Yes, I am trying to be funny at parts. I hope it worked. Just take what I write here lightly since I am a sarcastic person at times. Not a mean person, but certainly sarcastic).
Is it sad that I actually had to look up this weeks topic to figure out what it meant? I had a general idea but had no clue it was a commandment. It all came back to me once I did a simple Google search on the phrase. I was raised in a Catholic school as a youngster, but years of being agnostic must have made me forget the basics like that. Just for the record, I am agnostic, not atheist. There is a difference, really.
Sure, I remembered Thou Shall Not Kill and one about sleeping with your neighbors wife. The important ones I guess. Not to offend anyone, but I have chosen to base my morals not on a set of guidelines from the Bible, but from what I feel is genuinely right or wrong (basically not to hurt anyone, simple really). It is a good thing too because once I stopped believing in the certainty of God, I might have thrown all my morals out of the window if that was ALL I had based them on. Instead I have empathy for others and think about how it feels to have things done to me. If it was something that would hurt me (physically, mentally, or financially), then chances are it would make that other person feel the same way and thus, I did not want to do that to another person. Again, I am not saying every Christian is this way. I know many of you are wonderful, kind people because you sincerely care about others. I also know some that are not wonderful and kind for the sake of caring for others but because they are afraid of Gods wrath if they happen to do wrong.
But that is another topic for another time. Once I looked up this topic, I realized that this is still a rather important message. It just leaves some questions about its true intent.
Also, I found out that it was most likely talking about bearing false witness in a court of law. In Ancient Hebrew times, it was common practice for those who testified against someone to be punished with the same sentence that would have been imposed on the criminal if they were found to be lying, even if that meant death. They obviously took perjury very seriously back then.
For instance, it is often shortened, but the original wording had to do with not bearing false witness against ones neighbor. So as long as I don't make stuff about the guy living next door to me, it is fine? As long as I stick to people living a couple houses down I guess...
No, I am not an idiot, I promise. It really leaves it up to interpretation and I feel it should be that you should not bear false witness against anyone, no matter what street they live on. Lying in a court of law to convict an innocent person is a very serious offense and should be taken very seriously, be it your neighbor or some bum living on the street that you don't even know. Maybe that is why the “against ones neighbor” part is often left out since it seems to be a better moral fit.
Many people seem to throw the phrase around a lot these days. They will even use it to say how gossiping and bragging are wrong. While neither one are very nice, I don't feel they fit into this exact case. For instance, if what you are gossiping about is “true”, how does that qualify as being “false”? And bragging is usually about yourself, not your neighbor. So how does that make sense? Perhaps one should avoid doing such things if possible, but at least tell me a more reasonable explanation than the Bible says to not bear false witness if that doesn't happen to fit the scenario. Instead, focus on why gossiping hurts others and the damage it can cause emotionally. That makes more sense than quoting a Bible phrase that doesn't really fit the situation.
If it were to fit into any other contexts, it seems to be more in line with lying than bragging or gossiping. It might not be the original context, but I do see the connection. One should not lie. It is something we are taught very early on. However, what if a lie is necessary to avoid something far worse? How does that fit into the whole message of not lying? It is one thing to teach your kids to not lie and blame their sister for something they did. It is another thing to ask them to “lie” and not tell their mom or dad about a surprise birthday party when asked.
I now understand why this topic really confused me. My problem is I tend to take things very literally. I read things as it is stated and this topic wasn't something I could take very literally. It is up to interpretation on what is really means and thanks to changes in our culture since Hebrew times, the meaning of the phrase has obviously changed as well to reflect modern day society. However, I am happy to say I not only got a history lesson, my brain was put to work on trying to define what the topic meant to me. If anything else, I am thankful for that.